Friday, February 3, 2012

The future of this blog

So, yesterday I shut down access to all the previous blog posts.  A search came up on my sitemeter that I found alarming.  I'm not all that anonymous here, really, but I'm not going to be fired for what I've written.

Honestly, I've been thinking of taking this blog down for awhile. I'm not saving the world here.  My numbers aren't even that high; most days I don't even check my sitemeter or stats.  And I just don't want to be a rant blogger anymore.

The problem with blogging is that it's so easy to fall back into rant mode.  It's what people want to read, it's what gets the most audience participation and feedback.  I know my audience, and I've been guilty of writing what the audience wanted to hear - when I myself was in sympathy (or at least partly in sympathy) with those positions.

But I don't want to be Dr. Laura.  First off, no one really likes Dr. Laura.  They like to hear her stick it to annoying or immoral people, but they don't like her personally.  I don't want to be the fighting dog everyone roots for in the ring.  They also don't back up Dr. Laura.  They figure she can take it because she can dish it out, but her every misstep is hashed out by the public which must be hard to take.  I just want to be a normal person.  For about four years I had a normal person's blog.  I wrote about my kid, my garden, the books I read, the movies I saw.  Once in a while I went on a tear about something that upset me, but mostly I kept it clean.  And boring.  No one ever read it.

When I started the Lost Art blog I was very frustrated.  I'd been forced for years, in various jobs I'd done, to listen to other people's (mostly women's) very liberal opinions as if they were gospel and to at least tacitly sign off on lifestyles I thought were, at best, ill-advised.  In order to keep the peace, I tried to keep my mouth shut, but I built up quite a bit of resentment over time.  This blog has often been an escape valve for the steam I held in over the last decade, and as a result the rhetoric was often over-the-top or accusatory.  I still feel very frustrated with modern behavior, values and politics - I think they are an active hindrance to my raising my son to be a safe, productive, and good person.   But I don't want to spend my time nursing that anger.  I can't change the way things are or what other people do or believe.  I can only change how I behave and how I react to others.

I'm also a real person with real flaws.  I don't always follow the advice I give.  I can be lazy despite disdaining laziness.  I eat junk sometimes even as I grow, cook, eat, and promote organic food.  I don't always cook a five-course meal for my husband, and I sometimes lose it with my kid.  I put on two pounds over Christmas.  I have a knee-jerk tendency to make sweeping judgments.  The area I live in has experienced a rash of rather high-profile crimes, and I've begun to feel less safe.  This makes me more reactive and less objective - more prone to judge other people not on their intrinsic value (how God sees them), but on whether they are a threat to me and mine.  I think this is a human response, but I don't want to put it forward as admirable.

As I discussed a year or so ago when I reviewed The Fourth Turning, I think we are going through an unraveling, and I think this is going to result in some serious clashes - racial, class, generational - that are not going to be pleasant.  People are feeling their standard of living decline, and they sense that it's not temporary.  No one likes that, and we are all ready to place the blame on whomever is handy, guilty or not.  I have my own opinions, yes, but I don't for one minute believe that I am truly objective, and I don't want to be responsible for an attack on innocents.  I also don't want to foster more anger or hostility.  We'll all just have to survive as we can.  I've been more blessed than many in my family and my circumstances.

I don't know what to do with this blog, but for now I'm keeping most of my pieces of advice up as I think some have found them helpful.  Nearly all of the rants are down.  I realize this makes me less entertaining.  I'm willing to sacrifice that.

I didn't take this blog down as a stunt and I'm not holding it hostage until enough people tell me how wonderful I am.  I'm just unsure of how to proceed from here as a blogger or writer.  Your comments and prayers are always appreciated.

58 comments:

  1. Grerp,

    I liked your posts. They did help me.
    I hope you continue to blog.
    But I understand your position...

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think your posts have been interesting and worthwhile, and hope you decide to stick around.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sometimes I wonder if I'm wasting my time with blogging, so I understand this. You have written some good stuff and although you may not be "saving the world", you've been doing your part to offer an alternative voice to the constant drone of "if it feels good, do it". You may not reach everyone or prevent the ultimate collapse of the culture, but that doesn't mean what you do isn't worthwhile.

    I don't say that to try to convince you of what to do though; you have to work that out for yourself and if it's healthier for you to give up blogging, then that's the best thing to do and I wish you the best either way.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Grerp,

    I hope you keep the advice essays up, because they're GOOD STUFF that young women need to read. I was going to tell my brother & SIL about the blog, because they have three girls who are 3, 2, and 1 now. It won't be long before they reach their teen years and adulthood, and they could USE the knowledge you put out there.

    MarkyMark

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am so glad you put this up. I followed a link from another blog (cannot remember which one) just a few days ago and I have been going through your back archives it was so good.

    I was heartbroken when I tuned in today to do some reading and you werent here.
    I have nothing really helpful to tell you, except thank you for writing. I will keep you inmy prayers and Ilook forward to more writing it you do so.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Same here. I really like reading this, it's given me some good ideas for advising female friends when they need relationship advice. I've already gone back and gotten the blog backed up in a word doc, but I missed all the comments. Thankfully the waybackmachine caught a good bunch of the site, which is something worth considering--you are sill online, even after you're gone. With that being the case, does it really make sense to scuttle the blog?

      Delete
  6. Grerp, I hope you keep your pieces of advice up. I think every young woman would greatly benefit from your writings. If you ever publish them in book form, I'd gladly pick up a few copies for my hypothetical and in the far future daughters.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The ranty stuff is, of course, good fun.

    But I enjoy the boring domestic stuff, too. It's nice to see an existence proof of the marriage-quality woman, who is almost non-existent out here. It also sets a good example for the womenfolk.

    BTW: "Not going to get fired"? Thought you were a SAHM these days.

    Anyway, hope you keep writing, and follow through on the book. I'm unlikely to buy it, being very cheap these days, but would consider it as a gift for the women in my life.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I hope you keep it up for the same reasons the other commenters listed, but I also get the desire to stop ranting. There is value in the rants as a good rant can help one distill their points down into a more cogent and palatable form. The problems arise when you let the rants become an all-consuming focus on everything that is wrong with the world. That lens makes it harder to appreciate the good and, contrary to what many say, it's much easier to build upon and grow the good than it is to start from scratch. I don't want the world to come crashing down so as to vindicate my pessimism; I want to be proven wrong. Either outcome can become self-fulfilling, so I'd rather it be the latter.

    One posed a good question on the subject today. I think he's approaching things correctly.
    http://onestdv.blogspot.com/2012/02/contrarian-optimism.html

    ReplyDelete
  9. Grerp,

    I really appreciate your pieces of advice. Particularly since I'm a solo Dad, and lots of women won't listen to me -- I am not worthy of their attention because I'm divorced -- and you frequently say what I think.

    And I understand your fears. I have had a trollish woman from HR in my university say that she would not allow me to be hired because of what I said... on USENET in the days when it had a reasonable signal/noise ratio! If it unwise to be on blogspot, email me: I have space, or talk to Alte and Terri.

    And do not look at your readership numbers. [you should see mine -- they are low, low, low :-) ] That is immaterial. You are as a watchman on the wall. You say what needs to be said. You are not responsible for the audience you get, and you underestimate your influence.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'm sorry to hear that, but understand your position. Will it be possible to keep at least the pieces of advice up? As a single woman, it's comforting to read them.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Please stay. You've inspired me to be countercultural. I've really admired your sensible, yet very readable tone and style. I've gone back and re-read your previous posts often and am always happy to see when you've got a new one up. You would be MUCH missed. Shelly

    ReplyDelete
  12. By writing you let others know they're not alone.

    ReplyDelete
  13. "I'm also a real person with real flaws. I don't always follow the advice I give. I can be lazy despite disdaining laziness. I eat junk sometimes even as I grow, cook, eat, and promote organic food. I don't always cook a five-course meal for my husband, and I sometimes lose it with my kid. I put on two pounds over Christmas. I have a knee-jerk tendency to make sweeping judgments. "

    So, you are just a normal everyday kind of person like the rest of us, then?

    I am cut to the quick. ;)

    Look, it's just a blog Grep. Not real life.
    If you are torn, then the blog is obviously having a detrimental effect on you.

    Your husband, son and family are your priority here.

    Don't let something that is really very insignificant in the scheme of things affect the REALLY important things in your life.

    God Bless you and your family.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I have enjoyed your blog and hope that you continue in some fashion... but regardless of your decision, I wish you all the best in your endeavors.

    You have a clear and cogent way of saying what is not being said, and it is appreciated.

    ReplyDelete
  15. For my daughter's sake, I hope you write a book. I want something to give her to counteract what she will be exposed to in life. Simple as that really. If you ever get down about your writing, think of my daughter that you've never met but will help tremendously.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks for all of the comments. It's really good to know that my blog has made a difference to people out there. Thanks for letting me know.

    I should clarify that I'm not really worried about my job since I stay at home now (although I do have some volunteer work and I'd rather not be outed anyway). It's more that I can't be too outrageous under my real name because I may have to go back to work and it would be hard enough to break back into my profession without being labeled a certain way (people in my field are very liberal). I've been conscious of this the whole time I've been blogging. I understand that freedom of speech does not equal freedom from pushback, but I don't think I should be denied work and the ability to feed my child because of my political opinions.

    For now I'm keeping what is up up.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Grerp,

    I've been reading your blog for over a year and would very much like to get your advice in book form. I fear for my daughter's future and you articulate the dangers of current culture far better than I can/do. You really do underestimate your impact.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Dear Grerp,

    I am twenty year old young woman studying and living in a really "lefty" city (i.e. famous for its night life, beautiful women, easy access to pre-marital sex, excessive drinking culture etc.) I was recently linked to your blog via hookingupsmart.com. I put aside my homework for 2hours and read nearly all of the advice columns you wrote.

    Although I grew up in a household where a lot of your advice is followed - I never understood why. You gave me all the reasons and rationale I was looking for. It is so hard to find the sort of advice you give.

    On a different note, I do think my generation feels entitled to everything and I am afraid to end up on that path. Reading your advice posts have really grounded me and given me renewed hope and a sense of awareness to carry on with my life in a healthy, spiritual, and "preserved" way. I just sent two friends the link to your blog and I know many young women my age would benefit from your advice.

    I admire the dedication you have to your family, to living honestly, and with integrity. If you do choose to quit blogging, I hope maybe down the road you will consider publishing your advice and your life experiences.

    ReplyDelete
  19. If you have to quit, 100 pieces of advice is a good round number to quit on.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Grerp, you're wise about yourself and humanity. Nobody lives up to their ideals, but few admit it humbly & wilingly.

    Your pieces of advice are gold, and not many people are giving them. I've been planning on sending two sisters I know to come read this blog, as soon as I have the opportunity to get in a conversation about the topic.

    For all the women who haven't read this advice yet, and may not find it anywhere else, please leave that part up.

    But I would recommend pseudonymity to any blogger who doesn't have a particular reason to use their real name. I always comment under a pseudonym, and I don't even have a blog anymore.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Your blog started as advice for your niece, didn't it? If you've thoroughly explored what you wanted to say to her (and others in the same position), it is probably time to wrap it up. Many bloggers hang on too long after they've mined their particular subjects.

    I hope you will leave the advice posted. Better yet, make a book out of it! I'd buy it in a red-hot minute.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I have always perceived you to be a genuine and authentic blogger, not given to writing things to drum up hits.

    Because I tend to be the same way, it's inevitable that my blog sometimes sits without an update from time to time; sometimes for a couple of weeks, others for a couple of months.

    Sometimes we just run out of things to say. The beauty of readers and subscription sites like Bloglines is that when and if you suddenly find yourself with a burning need to write something, we'll know.

    Take care, Grerp.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Grerp,

    Please don't go! I have also corresponded with you personally, and while I am way outside the scope of your target audience, I love your posts, as they resonate to pretty much everything my ( well our) generation got wrong, and that you are trying to right, at least in your own life.

    You inspired me to want to start one of my own. Please, do it anonymously if you have to, its that good, and I promise, I won't "out" you :)

    ReplyDelete
  24. Grerp,

    I know what you mean about fearing social reprisal for your views because I faced something similar once, even though I don't live in a lefty city. A particular friend decided to not talk to me anymore when I decided to take her to task for an ignorant rant.

    In my experience leftists can be the most dogmatic and rigid people. Combining that with a woman's tendency to send out pings about other people's beliefs can't be fun to experience. I guess I'm lucky I don't have much face time with the women I work with.

    I always thought it was odd (and not altogether reasonable) that for someone blogging under a pseudonym, never stating any real names to be attacked. The reality is that people are imperfect. Blogging is a way for people to vent, discuss emotions, and otherwise communicate in a crass way if they wish. For some people, it's important.

    I support your assertion that you can have high goals/moral code while being an imperfect person. A hypocrite that at least tries to follow his own strict moral code is better than the rake who lives for himself, throwing everyone else under the bus.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I have $30 with your name on it when the book comes out.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Again, so many kind comments here - thanks so much for leaving them, everyone. I'm trying my best, and I will look into how I can put the pieces of advice, at least, into book form.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I feel I must move from lurker to poster at this news. I have no idea if your life or job are in jeopardy but truth always draws fire. Certainly there is no need to be an over the top ranter but you make no bones about being a Catholic which means one day you will stand before The Man described in Revelation 19 and he is going to ask some tough questions especially about truth telling. I would weigh up your decision (any decision) in light of that fact.

    Your blog is a great read and I'm a guy! My wife enjoys it as well. So here is a vote of support from us over here in HK. Your stuff is pretty Biblical - I am not sure thats on purpose or "accidental" but its good advice because its Biblical advice.

    Soli Deo Gloria

    /mm

    ReplyDelete
  28. I have been a faithful reader for the past year, but never commented due to time restrictions. I do hope you at least keep the pieces of advice up. Your blog has given the world a bit of common sense and truth it seems to be severely lacking. I love your blog. I hope you continue to post, but I do understand if you choose not to.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Regarding hypocrisy, it's not so much that I don't follow my own advice, as it is that I sometimes fail. Much of what I talk about here isn't even an issue for me anymore the way it is for younger women. I don't have to deal with the dating scene, for instance, because I'm married. The reason I wrote this blog skewed to a slightly younger audience is that there are so many mistakes you can make when you are young that will continue to affect you for years.

    I have my failings, but I try to hold myself accountable and scrutinize my own actions and reasoning often. So many of our society's problems stem from the fact that there is no accountability because we are now so anonymous - except in situations we choose not to be. But even then we choose what parts of ourselves to reveal. It was harder to misbehave when people lived in smaller towns and villages because everyone knew your business and called you out on it - which is probably why in the last century people left those small towns and moved to bigger cities. For the freedom.

    ReplyDelete
  30. And I should clarify as to why I'm re-evaluting the blog: honestly, I don't have that much more advice to give. I've kind of covered it, or at least brushed on most topics I would discuss with the audience I've picked to address. There may be some areas that need more work, and I may be able to say what those areas are when I go through and organize what I've written down here, but I don't want to hash our and rehash the same stuff forever. And I'd rather be active than reactive. Most of this stuff boils down to self-discipline, hard work, integrity, kindness, and future orientation. Common sense, really.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Grerp,

    I have profited from reading your posts. To an extent, as a 50-plus male who's working to better his own marriage, but more so as the dad of two 'tweens. As we get into the hormone-charged years, what sort of stance should I take with them?

    It's seemed to me that your 'advice' and 'rant' pieces all came from the same source. An author whose words I would visit here, to read.

    I think your concerns about the fishbowl aspect of blogging and how that fits into employment prospects are well-taken. I have blogged semi-anonymously about a politically-charged topic that interests me. To deviate from the current orthodoxy is to take a measured risk: in the age of Google, IP tracing, fast-evolving algorithms, and occasional late-night slipups, there can be no presumption of privacy. For myself, I mainly want to see my un-PC comments not overwhelm a search on my name.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Thin-Skinned Masta BetaFebruary 7, 2012 7:49 AM

    Hi Miss / Mrs. grerp,

    I'm sorry to see you go. Thanks to the recommendation by Susan Walsh I found you in the first place.

    I understand that you don't want all your remarks and the those of many of the clowns in the forum discussion rubbing off on your reputation in the real world. Nevertheless it's a shame every time somebody pulls the plug on some outlet of opinion and commentary, it seems like the entire volume of that work distributed in all the libraries in the world is annhilated at the press of a button on the whim of the author or publisher.

    For what it's worth, I wish that I had the voice and the things you have to say. Sure you're a sometimes lazy imperfect human, but I'm sure that many lurkers like I have learned something - even from your contributions that you now might not be so proud of.

    Maybe you would be better served adding a different pseudonymous outlet to share and experiment with untested thoughts and ideas. Indeed the biggest loss of our modern world is the loss of sincerity and readiness to consider ideas outside of threadbare dogmas that are somehow so important to the social acceptance of our personae. Who has the guts to think out loud any more, when weeks or years later somebody can pull up the permanent record to reveal some of the half-baked controversial notions that now would be an anathema to contemporary standards?

    Whatever you decide, thanks for the contributions while they lasted...

    ReplyDelete
  33. thank you for sharing what you have. i don't blame you at all for taking things down. it's a ashame that open dialogue is often not appreciated by those who claim to want an open dialogue.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Hi Grerp. Thanks for an awesome blog and great, insightful writing.

    I too found it easy to lapse into rant mode. To the point to where some who knew me and about my blog had an IRL blog intervention with me. Yikes.

    Take care, know that you made a difference and sowed some wisdom while you were at it.

    Blue skies,
    EW

    ReplyDelete
  35. Grerp,

    I just discovered your blog a few days ago but found it so compelling that I have read every post. Your writing can help many people and in my opinion, your blog is a magnificent achievement.

    People with traditionalist views are very rare these days. Sometimes it really helps to know that we're not alone. It's not always easy protecting your kids from the toxic popular culture, especially when some people will actually demonize you (freak!) for trying to keep your kids safe.

    Like you, I was born in 1971. The culture had already collapsed by the time I was a kid, but I could still see the remains of an older, healthier culture when I talked to my grandparents and other people from their of their generation. And there were still a few institutions around, like the Boy Scouts, that were still clean and decent.

    Today's kids don't have that, and my heart goes out to them. Fortunately the Boy Scouts are still around, but the WWII generation is all but gone now. Our generation could figure out how to lead a traditional life if we looked to our elders, but today's kids don't have it as easy.

    People like you are doing a great service to the younger generation by teaching them how to lead a traditional life. They don't get guidance from popular culture or from older generations. (My grandparents fought in WWII, married their spouses for life, and left their kids better off; today's kids have grandparents who were cowardly draft-dodging hippies who divorced multiple times and left a tangled family tree of half-brothers and step-sisters.)

    So what you are doing is very important. You really are helping younger people find their way through a society that is toxic.

    If you do have to take your blog down to protect yourself, do it. You've got to look after your family first. But thank you very much for creating it. It has helped me and I'm sure it has helped many others. Just by leading a traditional life, you are setting an example that helps people. If you can continue to help people on the Internet, that's fantastic; I hope you'll be able to. But you've already done a great deal. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Grerp,

    About a year ago I decided to make a major change in my life because I was not happy in my marriage, my work, or even just being home.

    I started studying Men's issues, at first just via Game, and then in a much broader sense. I saw a lot of things that my very feminist upbringing had embedded in my psyche that I needed to purge from myself. Psychological detritus that was eating away at my trust and self-esteem.

    The problem was, I was invested in feminist thought, and even when I knew it was bad for me, I had a hard time letting go of it or seeing it for its flaws. A lot of manosphere writers made me defensive.

    While I am not a woman, nor a parent, your blog has been an incredible help to me. It has helped me deprogram myself by holding up a mirror to an ideology I had taken to heart, without cruelty, malice, or hate. It was far from being the only tool in the toolbox I used for that task, but it has always been a favourite one.

    I now am trying to make a career of helping Men, because I feel that I have made a lot of mistakes living as one, mistakes I can help others avoid. I would greatly miss this blog, and your voice if they were to go away.

    I hope that if you do choose to end TLASP(FW), that you would consider binding your advice into a book or ebook, so that your fans could preserve it and mine it for inspiration, as I often do.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Grerp,
    Do you think you'll continue to comment around the 'Sphere even if you take down your blog?

    I hope not. You always have good insight on issues as we discuss them from the comments of yours I've seen around the 'Sphere.

    Curious, if your job saw the stuff here would they have cause to fire you? Makes me concerned for the stupidity of America that people can get fired from a full time job for this kind of thing. My own career is different - but that's because, in essence, I'm an independent contractor. So getting hired from job to job makes things a little more touchy.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Worded that wrong, oops! I hope you WON'T stop commenting around the 'Sphere, not that you will

    ReplyDelete
  39. Hi Grerp,
    I've been reading for a while now (just going thru the advice from the start) and while we don't agree on every point, and I am atheist, our moral compasses are definitely aligned.

    At 40-ish, I have left a lot of the anger and despair behind and am focusing my energy on the areas where I can have the greatest effect. I *can* model a good mother, wife and citizen to my daughters (most of the time!!) and devote my time to attempting (and helping my family) to navigate the perils of modern life and creating a refuge for us amidst the chaos.

    I have appreciated your efforts to date and would like to at least finish reading all your advice. :) I believe that your contribution is valuable regardless of the size of your readership. You only need to throw one pebble into a pond to start a ripple.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Your advice and previous posts will be missed but I applaud your choice to protect yourself and your family.

    I really found your advice refreshing and it was nice to find that other women "out there" in cyberspace that I mostly agreed with. I really liked knowing that there are communities where "regular" families live. *grin*

    I often have to watch what I say and step carefully around the cultural landmines as not repeating the party line enough can harm my husbands employment. Say the wrong thing about divorce (the wrong thing is anything other than support for the couple splitting up) or forget yourself and mention you don't allow your 4 year old to watch the Disney channel and you are the overprotective weirdo.

    Sometimes we feel under siege or we can feel a storm coming. I say pay attention to your hunch. I am so pleased I was able to read your advice posts before they were closed to the public.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Well, I was holding off on telling a 16-year-old about your blog until she was able to understand it... guess I waited too long.
    But she has NO sense of self-preservation, and makes the furry-toothed geek stereotype seen socially well-adjusted.

    In point of fact, she is the epitome of your target audience (IE, someone who needs a cold dose of reality), but she refuses to see it. I keep hoping the mind will catch up to the body, but again - those with good discipline and impulse control do not make good consumers (Read: Government-Approved citizens). I cannot block all access to the outside world, and she never had discipline as a child - I came on the scene rather late, and can only do so much.

    Wish you the best of luck! hope you'll keep commenting at least, as you usually speak reason instead of emotion. ;-)

    -Jean

    ReplyDelete
  42. Dear Grerp,

    I agree with each of the above comments.

    Thank you so much for what you HAVE written.

    I found your blog and it was like I was no longer alone in my thinking.

    Will miss the frisson of delight to see a new post and eagerly read your insights.

    Thank you, thank you , thank you....

    ReplyDelete
  43. If your employer or anybody gives you any shit, you contact me.

    ReplyDelete
  44. LOL. Cappy Cap's offering to WK for you, grerp. A higher compliment than which it is difficult to imagine.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Honestly, I am humbled by the comments left here. I've had some communication with readers over the time I've been blogging, but I didn't know it really meant what it seems to have meant to a number of you. Thank you. As I said, I'm leaving the advice pieces up and I will go over them to see if they've been truly comprehensive or not.

    And, Cappy Cap, you are very sweet. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Very Pregnant LadyFebruary 9, 2012 11:56 AM

    I've been a loyal reader of your blog ever since I came across it from MMSL. I think it really is one of the most refreshing things I've come across regarding the behavior of most women today. I'm a big believer in this issue, but never could really put it into words like you do. I hope I will be able to do one day because I'm about to give birth to a girl in April! Like one reader said, I hope you continue to do it anonymously, or keep giving advice, because young women would truly "wake-up" from reading it as I have. I really look up to you and still need and appreciate your leadership.

    ReplyDelete
  47. I haven't read the other comments yet, but please at least keep the archives up. Those few hits you get are real people whose lives you may change through your writing here. You helped contribute to my awakening. Don't underestimate the importance of your work here. Please leave it up for others, especially young women, who need the red pill.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Grerp: You're one of the only women in the 'sphere who really, truly gets it. I hope you don't go away. I hope you're around for a long, long time. Voices like yours are needed. Even if you can't save the world, please stick around to help save our corner of it.

    deti

    ReplyDelete
  49. Please don't go
    please don't go
    please don't go
    I'm begging you to stay

    You're the one of the few who understands please don't go

    ReplyDelete
  50. Well, I hope I didn't scare you. I note you removed the post about a certain city.

    The few times I've commented here before were congenial, and I don't think I gave you horrid pushback for your opinion about the most recent post you removed. So :
    A. I hope you decide to stay for the reasons others above have pointed out.
    B. I hope I was not in any way, shape or form the reason you were frightened. I felt I disagreed in a polite way and I didn't search for anything on your site.

    Clarence

    ReplyDelete
  51. Clarence - I didn't take the Detroit post down because I was scared. It was off topic, and I purged a lot of the OT and ranty stuff. You were congenial and definitely didn't scare me - no worries.

    ReplyDelete
  52. I have to tell you that I read that first line and immediately panicked and searched for your post on Cultivate Dignity because it has gotten me through in some trying times. Relieved to see it was still there I came back to finish this post.

    I think there is a lot of value in what you write and that's what keeps me coming back. Your advice is something I rarely find: practical, applicable, reserved and realistic. It is real advice. In college, I heard a lot of things about the world and what could be expected. How many opportunities would lie ahead for everyone. After college, reality twisted those pretty words I'd heard for years to something else. Your words feel closer to truth that most people I've heard about while still being optimistic.

    I don't know what you are going to do, but I am grateful that you shared what you did. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  53. You write very well, and your posts have been excellent. It will be a loss if you stop writing.

    ad*m

    ReplyDelete
  54. Unfortunately Gerp I think you're absolutely right. We are more polarized than ever before. Both sides of the spectrum on any issue are getting more militant. Things can't keep going the way they are and these days.

    I wouldn't worry about coming across as a 'ranter' though. You have always struck me as a restrained and objective blogger and you present your thoughts well.

    ReplyDelete
  55. "This makes me more reactive and less objective - more prone to judge other people not on their intrinsic value (how God sees them), but on whether they are a threat to me and mine. I think this is a human response, but I don't want to put it forward as admirable.'

    Actually, protecting you and yours is very admirable, and is in fact a mother's first duty under the natural law. Don't beat yourself up because you're not God - it's not given to us to see others intrinsic value.

    ReplyDelete
  56. It was good reading. Take care.

    ReplyDelete
  57. gosh I found your blog and really liked it and then I crash my computer.....then I finally find your blog again and you've stopped...sad face.It was really good, hope it wasn't anything to do with the wild rabbit trails I was following the day I ended up on your blog...if you can see where I had been it may have looked worrisome....just a middle age momma here hope you are able to write more again.karen

    ReplyDelete